A N A L I S I S Y U R I D I S P E M I D A N A A N B A G I P E L A K U A N A K D A L A M T I N D A K P I D A N A P E R S E T U B U H A N ( P U T U S A N N O M O R 7 8 7 / P I D / 2 0 1 1 / P T . S B Y )

Abstract

P e m i d a n a a n

t e r h a d a p

p e l a k u

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n

t e r h a d a p

a n a k

y a n g

d i j a t u h k a n ,

c e n d e r u n g

t e r l a m p a u

r i n g a n

d i

b a w a h

d a k w a a n

j a k s a

p e n u n t u t

u m u m ,

t e n t u n y a

h a l

t e r s e b u t

s a n g a t

i r o n i s

s e k a l i

m e n g i n g a t

k e r u g i a n

y a n g

d i a l a m i

k o r b a n

d a n

k e l u a r g a n y a

b a i k

s e c a r a

m a t e r i l

m a u p u n

i m m a t e r i l .

S e l a i n

i t u

a p a k a h

d e n g a n

s a n k s i

y a n g

b e g i t u

r i n g a n

t e r s e b u t

d a p a t

m e n y a d a r k a n

a t a u

m e m b u a t

s i

p e l a k u

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n

t e r h a d a p

a n a k

i n i

m e n j a d i

i n s a f

d a n

j e r a

u n t u k

m e n g u l a n g i

p e r b u a t a n n y a

t e r s e b u t ,

s e h i n g g a

s i

k o r b a n

b i s a

m e n d a p a t k a n

k e a d i l a n

s e p e r t i

y a n g

d i h a r a p k a n .

S e b a g a i m a n a

k a s u s

y a n g

d i k a j i

b e r d a s a r k a n

P u t u s a n

P e n g a d i l a n

T i n g g i

S u r a b a y a

N o m o r

7 8 7 / P I D / 2 0 1 1 /

P T . S B Y

y a n g

m e l i p u t i

2

( d u a )

h a l

p e r m a s a l a h a n ,

y a i t u

;

A p a k a h

k u a l i f i k a s i

p e r b u a t a n

t e r d a k w a

d a l a m

P u t u s a n

P e n g a d i l a n

T i n g g i

S u r a b a y a

N o m o r

7 8 7 / P I D / 2 0 1 1 / P T . S B Y

t e p a t

s e s u a i

d e n g a n

p a s a l

d a k w a a n

j a k s a

?

d a n

A p a k a h

a d a

u n s u r

k e s a l a h a n

y a n g

t e r b u k t i

s e h i n g g a

t e r d a k w a

h a r u s

b e r t a n g g u n g

j a w a b

d a l a m

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n

?

T u j u a n

p e n e l i t i a n

h u k u m

i n i

a d a l a h

U n t u k

m e n g e t a h u i

d a n

m e n g a n a l i s i s

k e s e s u a i a n

k u a l i f i k a s i

p e r b u a t a n

t e r d a k w a

d a l a m

P u t u s a n

P e n g a d i l a n

T i n g g i

S u r a b a y a

N o m o r

7 8 7 / P I D / 2 0 1 1 / P T . S B Y

d e n g a n

p a s a l

d a k w a a n

j a k s a

d a n

U n t u k

m e n g a n a l i s i s

u n s u r

k e s a l a h a n

y a n g

t e r b u k t i

s e h i n g g a

t e r d a k w a

h a r u s

b e r t a n g g u n g

j a w a b d a l a m

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n ,

T i p e

p e n e l i t i a n

y a n g

d i p e r g u n a k a n

d a l a m

p e n y u s u n a n

s k r i p s i

i n i

a d a l a h

Y u r i d i s

N o r m a t i f ,

a r t i n y a

p e r m a s a l a h a n

y a n g

d i a n g k a t ,

d i b a h a s

d a n

d i u r a i k a n

d a l a m

p e n e l i t i a n

i n i

d i f o k u s k a n

d e n g a n

m e n e r a p k a n

k a i d a h k a i d a h

a t a u

n o r m a n o r m a

d a l a m

h u k u m

p o s i t i f . m a k a

m e t o d e

p e n e l i t i a n

d a l a m

p e n u l i s a n

s k r i p s i

i n i

m e n g g u n a k a n

p e n d e k a t a n

m a s a l a h

p e n d e k a t a n

u n d a n g u n d a n g

( s t a t u t e

a p p r o a c h ) ,

d a n

s t u d i

k a s u s

( c a s e

s t u d y ) ,

A d a p u n

s u m b e r

b a h a n

h u k u m

y a n g

d i g u n a k a n

d a l a m

p e n u l i s a n

s k r i p s i

i n i

m e l i p u t i

: B a h a n

h u k u m

p r i m e r

t e r d i r i

d a r i :

U n d a n g U n d a n g

R e p u b l i k

I n d o n e s i a

N o m o r

1

T a h u n

1 9 4 6

t e n t a n g

P e r a t u r a n

H u k u m

P i d a n a ( K U H P ) . U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o m o r

8

T a h u n

1 9 8 1

t e n t a n g

K i t a b

U n d a n g

U n d a n g

H u k u m

A c a r a

P i d a n a ( K U H A P ) . U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o m o r

3

t a h u n

1 9 9 7

t e n t a n g

P e n g a d i l a n

A n a k

U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o m o r

4

T a h u n

1 9 7 9

t e n t a n g

K e s e j a h t e r a a n

A n a k U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o m o r

2 3

T a h u n

2 0 0 2

t e n t a n g

P e r l i n d u n g a n

A n a k

P u t u s a n

P e n g a d i l a n

T i n g g i

S u r a b a y a

N o m o r

7 8 7 / P I D / 2 0 1 1 / P T . S B Y .

x i i i

K e s i m p u l a n

p e n e l i t i a n

y a n g

d i p e r o l e h

a n t a r a

l a i n

a d a l a h ,

P e r t a m a

:

K u a l i f i k a s i

p e r b u a t a n

t e r d a k w a

a d a l a h

d e n g a n

s e n g a j a

m e l a k u k a n

p e r b u a t a n

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n

t e r h a d a p

s a k s i

k o r b a n

y a n g

m a s i h

b e r u m u r

1 5

t a h u n

d a l a m

k e a d a a n

s a d a r

d a n

d a p a t

d i p e r t a n g g u n g j a w a b k a n

a t a s

t i n d a k a n n y a

s e s u a i

d e n g a n

p a s a l

d a k w a a n

j a k s a

s e b a g a i m a n a

d i a t u r

d a l a m

k e t e n t u a n

P a s a l

8 1

a y a t

( 2 )

U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o . 2 3

T a h u n

2 0 0 2

t e n t a n g

P e r l i n d u n g a n

S e d a n g k a n

p a s a l

8 2

U n d a n g U n d a n g

N o . 2 3

T a h u n

2 0 0 2

t e n t a n g

P e r l i n d u n g a n

A n a k

t i d a k

s e s u a i

d e n g a n

k u a l i f i k a s i

p e r b u a t a n

t e r d a k w a

y a n g

d i d a k w a k a n

j a k s a

k a r e n a

t i d a k

t e r d a p a t

u n s u r

m e l a k u k a n

k e k e r a s a n

a t a u

a n c a m a n

k e k e r a s a n .

D a n

k e d u a

U n s u r

k e s a l a h a n

t e r d a k w a

s e c a r a

s a h

d a n

m e y a k i n k a n

d i n y a t a k a n

t e r b u k t i

y a i t u

d e n g a n

s e n g a j a

m e l a k u k a n

s e r a n g k a i a n

k e b o h o n g a n ,

a t a u

m e m b u j u k

a n a k

b e r s e t u b u h

d e n g a n n y a .

d a n

m a m p u

b e r t a n g g u n g

j a w a b

a t a s

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

p e r s e t u b u h a n

s e h i n g g a

m e n j a l a n i

s a n k s i

p i d a n a

p e n j a r a

s e l a m a

2

( d u a )

t a h u n

d a n

d e n d a

s e b e s a r

R p .

6 0 . 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 ,

( e n a m

p u l u h

j u t a

r u p i a h )

d e n g a n

k e t e n t u a n

a p a b i l a

d e n d a

t e r s e b u t

t i d a k

d i b a y a r

a k a n

d i g a n t i

d e n g a n

p i d a n a

k u r u n g a n

s e l a m a

1

( s a t u )

b u l a n .

B e r d a s a r k a n

p e r t i m b a n g a n

h u k u m

M a j e l i s

H a k i m

T i n g k a t

P e n g a d i l a n

N e g e r i

L u m a j a n g

d a n

v i s u m

e t

r e p e r t u m

N o . V E R / 2 2 2 / I X / 2 0 1 1 / R u m k i t

a t a s

n a m a

s a k s i

k o r b a n

s e h i n g g a

d i n y a t a k a n

b e r s a l a h .

B e r t i t i k

t o l a k

k e p a d a

p e r m a s a l a h a n

y a n g

a d a

d a n

d i k a i t k a n

d e n g a n

k e s i m p u l a n

y a n g

t e l a h

d i k e m u k a k a n

d i

a t a s ,

m a k a

d a p a t

s a y a

b e r i k a n

b e b e r a p a

s a r a n

s e b a g a i

b e r i k u t

p e r t a m a

J a k s a

P e n u n t u t

U m u m

d a l a m

m e n g u r a i k a n

c a r a

p e r b u a t a n

t e r d a k w a

m e l a k u k a n

t i n d a k

p i d a n a

h a r u s

s e s u a i

d e n g a n

p a s a l

y a n g

d i d a k w a k a n ,

y a i t u

P a s a l

8 1

a y a t

( 2 )

d a n

P a s a l

8 2

y a n g

u n s u r

p a s a l n y a

y a n g

b e r b e d a

s e h i n g g a

t i d a k

d a p a t

c o p y

p a s t e .

K e d u a

H a k i m

a n a k

d a l a m

m e n j a t u h k a n

p u t u s a n

b e r u p a

p e m i d a n a a n

t e r h a d a p

t e r d a k w a

a n a k ,

h a r u s

m e m p e r h a t i k a n

s i s t e m

s a n k s i

d a n

p e m i d a n a a n

d e n g a n

h a r a p a n

d a r i

M a j e l i s

H a k i m

d a n

s e s u a i

d e n g a n

t u j u a n

d a r i

d i b u a t n y a

U U

T e n t a n g

P e r l i n d u n g a n

A n a k